What merchants are struggling with
These are the most frequently reported pain points in the checkout optimization space, aggregated across every insight in this hub. The frequency count reflects how many merchant posts mentioned each issue.
Confusion caused by express checkout buttons leading to lost conversions.
criticalFailures during checkout and order processing for large orders
criticalLimited customization of the Thank You page
highHigh return rates on cash on delivery orders
criticalCheckout abandonment due to minimum charge requirements when using store credit.
highIncorrect mobile number entry when selecting COD leading to order processing issues
criticalMerchants, in their own words
Real quotes from Shopify Community threads, sorted by urgency signal. Each quote is linked back to the insight it supports, so you can see the full merchant context and competitive landscape.
"Frustration is growing because of lost sales and concern about leaving the platform."
"In india more than 75% order are placed using COD and 30% to 40% order are return without even opening the box and it’s hurts."
"These buttons are mistakenly causing my customers to leave my website without completing their order."
"mobile number should be verified by sending an OTP on mobile number and if he succeeds then only order should be forward"
"This is really important for both customer experience and conversion tracking."
Most-requested features
These are the specific features Shopify merchants asked for across the checkout optimization hub. Priority is weighted by request volume times average urgency.
-
Improved handling of large carts/orders during checkoutRequested by 5 merchants · Priority 9/10
-
Customization options for the Thank You / Order Status pageRequested by 4 merchants · Priority 8/10Implementation: Checkout UI Extensions, HTML, JavaScript, Liquid variables
-
Ability to disable express checkout buttons without removing payment methodsRequested by 3 merchants · Priority 9/10
-
Reliable workaround for draft orders imported by CSVRequested by 3 merchants · Priority 8/10
-
Ability to add product recommendations and upsells on the Thank You pageRequested by 3 merchants · Priority 7/10Implementation: Apps for product recommendations and upsells
Top 10 opportunities in this hub
Prepaid-Order Discount & COD Reduction App
An app that lets merchants offer automatic discounts or incentives only when customers choose prepaid payment methods instead of cash on delivery. It helps reduce COD-related returns by nudging buyers toward online payment at checkout.
Express Checkout Button Visibility Manager
An app that lets merchants selectively hide or de-emphasize express checkout buttons in cart and checkout based on market, device, customer type, or payment setup. It helps reduce customer confusion when local payment methods are more important than Shop Pay, Apple Pay, PayPal, or Google Pay.
Store Credit Rounding Protector
An app that automatically handles tiny leftover balances when customers pay with store credit, preventing checkout friction caused by payment minimums. It can round down, waive sub-$0.50 remainders, or prompt alternative payment methods before checkout fails.
COD Mobile OTP Verification App
An app that verifies phone numbers by sending a one-time password before allowing cash-on-delivery orders to be placed. It helps merchants reduce fake, mistyped, or invalid COD orders.
Thank You Page Redirect Fixer for Wallet Payments
An app that ensures wallet and alternative-payment checkouts like Vipps/MobilePay return customers to Shopify’s native order status and thank-you pages. It also helps merchants preserve conversion tracking and post-purchase flows when payment providers misroute the customer.
Custom Post-Purchase Thank You Page Builder
An app that lets merchants create branded, customizable post-purchase and order status experiences without needing Shopify Plus. It would support upsells, recommendations, coupons, surveys, and embedded content on the Thank You page and order status page.
Large Order Checkout Stabilizer
An app that helps merchants prevent checkout failures on very large carts by automatically splitting, batching, or simplifying oversized orders before Shopify checkout times out. It also flags risky carts and offers a guided fallback flow so merchants do not lose high-value sales.
Checkout Address Validation for Cross-Border Orders
An app that validates shipping addresses in real time and flags formatting issues, missing postal data, or invalid international addresses before orders are placed. It reduces failed deliveries, manual support work, and tax/duties errors caused by bad addresses.
Checkout Shipping Error Monitor
An app that scans shipping and pickup configurations for mismatches that cause checkout failures, then flags the likely reason before customers hit the error. It helps merchants detect hidden shipping-zone, pickup, or rate-eligibility issues that are hard to reproduce.
Shop Pay / Dynamic Buy Button Diagnostic & Fix Assistant
An app that checks why Shopify’s dynamic buy now button is rendering incorrectly, such as showing a gray Shop payment option on mobile or desktop. It guides merchants through theme, payment, cache, and configuration issues and can surface actionable fixes without needing a developer.
Explore related hubs
Frequently asked
What Shopify checkout optimization opportunities are merchants asking for right now?
We tracked 16 validated opportunities in this area, backed by 16 merchant posts across the Shopify Community and related forums. The most frequently cited pain point is "Confusion caused by express checkout buttons leading to lost conversions.". The top opportunity by quality score is "Prepaid-Order Discount & COD Reduction App".
How confident is AppScout in these checkout optimization?
Average confidence across this hub is 82%, computed from merchant post volume, unique merchant diversity, and urgency signals extracted from each thread. Insights are only promoted to this page when their qualityScore is 50 or higher, so every listing has been validated by at least one real merchant discussion.
Who should build checkout optimization apps for Shopify?
Indie developers and early-stage SaaS teams are the best-positioned. Each opportunity here comes with the merchant quotes and feature requests you need to validate the idea in a weekend, plus pain-point frequency to help you prioritize your MVP scope. Open any listing below for the full breakdown.
Find your next Shopify app opportunity in 60 seconds
Start a 7-day free trial and generate your own insights from live merchant discussions.
Start free trial